1960 –
Age of Post-Colonialism

Ai Weiwei's "Remembering"
and the Politics of Dissent

Ai Weiwei's So Sorry, 2010
Ai Weiwei, Remembering, backpacks, Haus der Kunst,* Munich, 2009

Dangerous Art

All art is political in the sense that all art takes place in the public arena and engages with
an already existing ideology. Yet there are times when art becomes dangerously political
for both the artist and the viewers who engage with that art. Think of Jacques-Louis David's
involvement in the French Revolution—his individual investment in art following the bloodshed
—and his imprisonment during the reign of terror. If it were not for certain sympathisers,
David may well have ended up another victim of the guillotine. Goya is another example of
an artist who fell foul of government power. There are instances in the 20th century when
artists have faced down political power directly. Consider the photomontages of John 
Heartfield. Heartfield risked his life at times to produce covers for the magazine A/Z, which
defied both Hitler and the Nazi Party.

Ai Weiwei
The Chinese artist, Ai Weiwei, offers is an important contemporary example. Recently, Weiwei
was arrested in China following a crack down by the government on so-called “political
dissidents” (a specific category that the Chinese government uses to classify those who seek
to subvert state power) for “alleged economic crimes” against the Chinese state. Weiwei has
used his art to address both the corruption of the Chinese communist government and its
outright neglect of human rights, particularly in the realm of the freedom of speech and

Weiwei has been successful in using the internet (which is severely restricted in China) as a
medium for his art. His work is informed by two interconnected strands, his involvement with
the Chinese avant-garde group “Stars” (which he helped found in 1978 during his time in the
Beijing Film Academy) and the fact that he spent some of his formative years in New York,
engaging there with the ideas of conceptual art, in particular the idea of the readymade.
Many of the concepts and much of the material that Weiwei uses in his art practice are
informed by post-conceptual thinking.

Ai Weiwei, Sunflower Seeds, Tate Modern
Ai Weiwei, Sunflower Seeds, painted porcelain, 2010

An International Audience
Weiwei has exhibited successfully in the West in many major shows, for example, the 48th
Venice Biennale in Italy (1999) and Documenta 12 (2007). He also exhibited Sunflower Seeds
(October, 2010) in the Turbine Hall in the Tate Modern. In this work, Weiwei filled the floor of
the huge hall with one hundred million porcelain seeds, each individually hand-painted in the
town of Jingdezhen by 1,600 Chinese artisans. Participants were encouraged to walk over the
exhibited space (or even roll in the work) in order to experience the ideas of the effect of
mass consumption on Chinese industry and 20th-century China's history of famine and
collective work. However, on 16 October, Tate Modern stopped people from walking on the
exhibit due to health liability concerns over porcelain dust.
Ai Weiwei, Sunflower Seeds, 2010
Ai Weiwei, Sunflower Seeds, painted porcelain, 2010

"...a natural disaster is a public matter."
Perhaps the work that contributed most to Weiwei’s current imprisonment and the destruction
of his studio was his investigation of corruption in the construction of the schools that collapsed
during the 2008 earthquake in Sichuan, China. Like many others, Weiwei investigated how
improper material and the contravention of civil engineering laws led to the wholesale
destruction of schools (which led in turn to the deaths of thousands of children trapped within
them), Weiwei has produced a list of all the victims of the earthquake on his blog. This act is
typical Weiwei's use of the internet to communicate information. This information is his “art”,
in much the way that American artists of the late 1960s used words and ideas as art.

Ai Weiwei, So Sorry, 2010
Ai Weiwei, Remembering, backpacks, Haus der Kunst,* Munich, 2009

So Sorry

In his retrospective show So Sorry (October 2009 to January 2010, Munich, Germnay), Weiwei
created the installation Remembering on the façade of the Haus der Kunst. It was constructed from
nine thousand children's backpacks. They spelled out the sentence “She lived happily for seven
years in this world” in Chinese characters (this was a quote from a mother whose child died in
the earthquake). Regarding this work, Weiwei said,

The idea to use backpacks came from my visit to Sichuan after the earthquake in May
2008. During the earthquake many schools collapsed. Thousands of young students lost
their lives, and you could see bags and study material everywhere. Then you realize
individual life, media, and the lives of the students are serving very different purposes.
The lives of the students disappeared within the state propaganda, and very soon
everybody will forget everything.

The title of the show referred to the apologies frequently expressed by governments and
corporations when their negligence leads to tragedies, such as the collapse of schools
during the earthquake. Two months before the opening of this exhibition Weiwei suffered a
severe beating from Chinese police in Chengdu in August 2009, where he was trying to testify
for Tan Zuoren, a fellow investigator of the shoddy construction and the student casualties.
Weiwei underwent emergency brain surgery for internal bleeding as a result of the assault.

The Arrest
On April 3rd 2011, Weiwei was arrested at Beijing's airport while while waiting for a flight to
Hong Kong. While his detention is broadly believed to be linked to his criticism of the Chinese
government, the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs has declared that he is “under investigation
for alleged economic crimes.” Weiwei's participation in the Jasmine Rallies, a series of peaceful
protests which took place all over China in February, no doubt contributed to his arrest.
Ai Weiwei, So Sorry, 2010
Ai Weiwei, Remembering, backpacks, Haus der Kunst,* Munich, 2009

Weiwei’s fate remains unclear, but he reminds us that art still affect us on a deeply political
level and can still threaten authoritarian regimes.

Text by JP McMahon

*Historical Note on the Haus der Kunst:
The Haus der Kunst (designed by Paul Ludwig Troost, "first master builder to the führer") was
sited by Adolf Hitler and sought to express Nazi ideology by using stone from German quarries
and with its references to the work of Klenze and Schinkel. From its opening in 1937, the Haus
der Kunst held exhibitions glorifying the "Blood and Soil" propaganda of the Nazi regime.

Here is Ai Weiwei's TED Video:

Your Comments (1)

Previous Comments

Joe Wagner wrote on Thursday, May 31, 2012

Update: Ai Weiwei was released last year but is still under some restrictions according to BBC and AP.

Add Comments

We think Smarthistory works best when it prompts discussion. Please post (on-topic) comments.*

*All comments are moderated

To post a comment, you need the Adobe Flash Plugin. Download it from here.
This work is an open educational resource and This work is licensed under a Creative Common Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 license.